All the pizzas on this special menu have been created by employees and customers of BTNYP. You won't find these pies on our regular menu so check back here to see what our latest creations are.
(no half & half - no substitutions)
Don't wait on the phone, ORDER ONLINE!
Our own 'prison pie'. Macaroni and cheese topped with Nathan's Famous all beef or polish dogs.
The colors of the flag! Spinach, feta and sun dried tomatoes on an olive oil base.
In honor of our friend Seafair Pirate Jon.....
Artichoke hearts, mushrooms, roasted red peppers and Italian sausage.
Canadian bacon, bacon and pepperoni
The Double RC
One of our original Pizzaman pies. Roasted peppers, whole milk ricotta and chicken breast on an olive oil base.
Similar to our Brooklyn, this is a tasty spin-off with Italian sausage, black olives and pepperoni on a red base.
Inspired by our wing menu. Our house made Blue cheese dressing base topped with mozzarella and chicken breast tossed in Spicy Frank's sauce.
Chicken, Bacon, Ranch!! This is an employee fave, chicken breast, real bacon, red onion and our famous Ranch dressing as the base.
What is MR PIZZAMAN drinking with his pizza pie????
Always one of our vintage sodas. Ask about our classic soda flavors on your next visit. Locally made in bottles they quench your thirst while dining in but can easily be taken to go or delivered.